[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: Full Masters Results - correct this time.(I hope)

To: brass-band@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Subject: Re: Full Masters Results - correct this time.(I hope)
From: Norm Harris <normal@xxxxxxxxxxxx>
Date: Tue, 26 May 1998 01:20:48 +1000
Priority: low
References: <199805251118.MAA14307@boober.lineone.net>
Reply-to: brass-band@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

IF you look at the placings/ ratings/ rankings given by the adj's, given that
they concur within + / - 2 in rankings, Brand & Crees agree 5 times, Brand &
Relton agreed 7 times, and Relton and Crees agreed 15 times. They all three
agreed 5 times and all three disagreed 4 times with only 1 "no question about
where they deserve to be". i.e. total agreement. It is obvious (?) that the
rankings are summed to derive the 'contentious' result, and where there is a
*tie*, the band that received the lowest ranking from any adj got the nod. e.g.
places 8 & 9.

Had they been asked to award the 'traditional points' would the result have
been any different.? Maybe not, because Mr Brand's results would still have
tilted the 'ledger' as he heard it.
One thing is for sure, ......	     absolutely nothing.

JEREMY P WISE wrote:

> The results are as follows: The adjudicators were Brand, Crees and Relton
> and I have put their positions in that order. Where on earth is the
> consistency here? Brand appears to be the oddball with the other two
> agreeing generally.
>
> 1Brighouse		   3 2 4
> 2 Fairies		       2 7 2
> 3 JJB			   7 3 3
> 4 YBS			13 1 1
> 5 Rothwell		   6 4 6
> 6 Fodens		    9 5 5
> 7 GUS			5 9 13
> 8 Ever Ready	      15 6 8
> 9 Sovereign		12 8 9
> 10 Aveley		   4 13 14
> 11 Sellers		  20 10 7
> 12 Ransomes	    1 20 17
> 13 EYMS		  18 11 11
> 14 Wingates	      17 12 11
> 15 Woodfalls	     16 16 10
> 16 Imps		    11 17 15
> 17 Besses		14 14 16
> 18 Redbridge	     10 15 19
> 19 Bodmin		 8 18 18
> 20 Flowers		19 19 20
> 21 Rhodian		21 21 21

Norm.
Music is my first love, after Jan and the billies.

--
unsubscribe or receive the list in digest form, mail a message of 'help' to
listserver@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

References:
- Full Masters Results - correct this time.(I hope)
  - From: JEREMY P WISE

Prev by Date: Re: City of Oxford
Next by Date: Re: City of Oxford appeal - long
Previous by thread: Full Masters Results - correct this time.(I hope)
Next by thread: Re: Full Masters Results - correct this time.(I hope)
Index(es):
- Date
- Thread