[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: Malcolm Brownbill & Shelly Hill

To: brass-band@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Subject: Re: Malcolm Brownbill & Shelly Hill
From: CAROL MOSS <cmss30@xxxxxxxxxxx>
Date: 20 Mar 2001 16:41:24 -0800

On Tue, 20 March 2001, "Shelley Hill" wrote:
Sorry Shelly but i disagree with you....you did make a judgment on Malcolm Brownbill !
If you knew the man you would know that he is nothing but a professional in everything he does.
He is well respected in the brass band world, would never go into the adjudicators box with out thoroughly studying the piece as if he was conducting a band in the contest himself.

I'm sorry but think you owe an apology !

And while i agree that the system needs to be updated and healthy debate is good!
I do think that to use Malcolm as an example is wrong !!!!
He is one of the best adjudicators around.
I make no apologies if this upsets you, but think you should get the facts right if you are going to sleight somebodies name on the list.
Carol Moss.
P.S.
Please let this be the last on ADJUDICATORS....It's getting boring now !!!!!
>
> Mike (and others)-
>
> I make (and made) no judgment about Mr Brownbill one way or the other.  I
> was merely relating what he said before he made the announcement and
> querying it.
>
> I did this out of a genuine interest in inspiring debate about a system
> which, it seems to me, a lot of bandsmen agree does not work particularly
> well.  I find it
> amazing that so many of us can agree that it is riddled with holes yet it
> has remained the same for so long!
>
> Shelley
>
>
>
>
> --
>
>
> njh@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
>
> http://www.normans.co.uk
>
>     unsub brass-band
>     end

--

Prev by Date: Re: Adjudicators
Next by Date: MANX NATIONAL YOUTH BAND - MANX CONCERT BRASS
Previous by thread: Epsom and Ewell Band
Next by thread: MANX NATIONAL YOUTH BAND - MANX CONCERT BRASS
Index(es):
- Date
- Thread